The decision to migrate from Magento to Shopify Plus is a significant strategic move for any ecommerce business. While Magento offers robust customization, many brands find it requires substantial technical resources, higher maintenance costs, and complex management that can hinder business agility. Shopify Plus, by contrast, provides a streamlined, scalable operation with lower maintenance requirements, built-in hosting, and an intuitive interface that empowers marketing teams to make changes without constant developer support.
Selecting the right migration partner is critical to ensuring a seamless transition that preserves your data, SEO equity, and business continuity. The ideal specialist will combine technical expertise with strategic insight to not only move your data but also optimize your store for growth. Here, we profile ten of the top Magento to Shopify migration specialists in the US, based on their expertise, client results, and industry reputation.
Key Selection Criteria for Migration Specialists
When evaluating migration partners, consider these essential factors:
- Technical Expertise & Certification: Look for Shopify Plus partners with certified developers who understand both platforms intimately.
- Proven Methodology: A structured process for discovery, data mapping, testing, and launch is non-negotiable.
- SEO Preservation: The agency must have a proven strategy for implementing 301 redirects and transferring metadata to protect your organic traffic.
- Portfolio & Case Studies: Review their success with businesses of your size and complexity, with documented metrics like improved conversion rates and revenue growth.
- Post-Launch Support: Ensure they offer ongoing support to address any issues and help optimize after go-live.
Top 10 Magento to Shopify Migration Specialists in the US
1. Netalico Commerce
Location: USA (Multiple Offices)
Highlight: Netalico stands out as a premier migration expert, demonstrated by their recent work with Audio Advice, a high-end audio retailer. Their migration to Shopify Plus resulted in a 21% increase in overall revenue, a 28% increase in orders, and a remarkable 47% lift in conversion rate year-over-year. Netalico's comprehensive approach included using Matrixify for seamless data transfer, creating custom product listing pages with advanced filtering, and ensuring 100% Core Web Vitals compliance (up from 0% on Magento).
Ideal For: Mid-market to enterprise businesses looking for a white-glove, full-service migration partner.
Services: End-to-end migration, custom Shopify development, SEO strategy, and post-launch support.
Learn More: Expert eCommerce Platform Migrations | Netalico
Case Study: Audio Advice Case Study on Shopify.com | Netalico's Case Study Page
2. Amasty
Location: USA (Global Team)
Highlight: An Adobe-certified partner with deep Magento expertise, Amasty offers managed migration services with an emphasis on data security and SEO preservation. Their structured 6-step process covers prioritization planning, secure data transfer, theme migration, and thorough QA testing. A key advantage is their inclusion of 2 months of post-launch support with every project.
Ideal For: Businesses prioritizing data security and a methodical, well-documented migration process.
Services: Managed migration, theme customization, custom feature recreation, and extended support.
3. IWD Agency
Location: Baton Rouge, LA
Highlight: Specializing in AI-driven personalization and B2B commerce, IWD Agency focuses on data integrity and system performance during migration. They excel at setting a strong foundation for future scalability and innovation.
Ideal For: B2B companies and brands looking to integrate advanced personalization and scalability features.
Services: Magento development, B2B solutions, AI personalization, and data migration.
4. Ecommerce Pro
Location: USA
Highlight: A certified Shopify Plus Migration Agency, Ecommerce Pro emphasizes strategic planning and post-migration optimization. They help brands leverage Shopify's automation capabilities and app ecosystem to streamline operations and drive growth.
Ideal For: Brands seeking a partner focused on long-term growth and operational efficiency.
Services: Migration planning, data transfer, theme design, and post-launch optimization.
5. Shero Commerce
Location: USA
Highlight: A dedicated Shopify Plus Agency, Shero Commerce emphasizes thorough planning and discovery to ensure a seamless transition with minimal downtime and SEO impact. They offer strong post-launch support and growth marketing strategies.
Ideal For: Brands seeking a partner invested in their long-term success beyond the initial migration.
Services: Shopify design, development, SEO, migrations, and growth marketing.
6. Transform Agency
Location: Poland (serves US clients)
Highlight: Transform Agency provides a personalized roadmap for each migration project. They stand out by including theme and extension migration, thorough testing, and 2 months of post-migration support in their service offering.
Ideal For: Businesses that value detailed planning and a clear, structured roadmap for their project.
Services: Custom software solutions, Magento migration, theme and extension migration.
7. Scandiweb
Location: New York and Latvia
Highlight: As a certified and innovative company, Scandiweb partners with all leading PIM, ERP, and CMS platforms. They are experts in identifying risks early, carefully transferring all data, and setting up stores without impacting daily operations, boasting 99.99% uptime.
Ideal For: Enterprise-level businesses with complex integrations and a need for maximum uptime.
Services: End-to-end migration, enterprise solutions, and system integration (PIM/ERP).
8. Ziffity
Location: Texas, USA (with offices in UK and India)
Highlight: Ranked as the 4th top Magento contribution partner globally, Ziffity brings strong enterprise-grade expertise to the table. They have a comprehensive understanding of diverse commerce models (B2B, B2C, B2B2C) and offer detailed discovery processes and strategic roadmapping.
Ideal For: Mid-market and enterprise businesses looking for a partner with deep Magento roots and enterprise capabilities.
Services: Magento implementation, enterprise solutions, managed services, and custom development.
9. IT-Geeks
Location: Salt Lake City, United States
Highlight: With over 7 years and 5,000+ projects of experience, IT-Geeks is a highly-rated Shopify firm known for competitive pricing and comprehensive service. Their migration package includes everything from data upload and URL redirects to payment and shipping setup.
Ideal For: Businesses looking for an experienced, all-in-one solution with a proven track record.
Services: Store migration, design, development, optimization, and SEO.
10. Clovecode
Location: Palampur, India (serves global clients)
Highlight: Clovecode receives exceptional client praise for its efficient merging of options and seamless integration of crucial features like reviews and various systems. They are noted for empowering clients to take control of their stores post-migration, reducing reliance on external developers.
Ideal For: Merchants looking for an efficient, cost-effective migration with excellent knowledge transfer.
Services: Store migration, administrative setup, theme design, and payment configuration.
Table: Comparison of Top Migration Specialists
| Company | Key Strength | Ideal For | Post-Launch Support |
|---|---|---|---|
| Netalico Commerce | White-glove, strategic full-service partner | Mid-market to enterprise businesses | Ongoing retainer options |
| Amasty | Secure, methodical 6-step process | Data-sensitive businesses | 2 months included |
| IWD Agency | B2B & AI personalization expertise | B2B and complex brands | Varies by project |
| Ecommerce Pro | Strategic planning & growth optimization | Brands focused on long-term scalability | Ongoing optimization |
| Shero Commerce | Long-term growth partnership | Growth-focused brands | Continued support & strategies |
| Transform Agency | Detailed personalized roadmap | Clients who want structured planning | 2 months included |
| Scandiweb | Enterprise integration & maximum uptime | Large enterprises with complex systems | Expert support |
| Ziffity | Enterprise-grade solutions & roadmapping | Mid-market to enterprise businesses | Managed services available |
| IT-Geeks | Comprehensive service & competitive pricing | Businesses wanting an all-in-one solution | Not specified |
| Clovecode | Efficient integration & client empowerment | Merchants seeking cost-effectiveness & control | Not specified |
The Migration Process: What to Expect
A typical expert-led migration follows a structured path:
- Discovery & Planning: A thorough audit of your existing site to map all data, extensions, and custom functionalities.
- Data & SEO Strategy: Cleaning and organizing data while developing a comprehensive URL redirect plan.
- Design & Development: Theme customization or creation on Shopify, followed by secure data transfer and recreation of custom features.
- QA & Testing: Rigorous testing of all functionalities, data accuracy, and performance across devices before launch.
- Launch & Support: Going live during a low-traffic period followed by close monitoring and ongoing support to ensure stability.
Challenges and Solutions in Magento to Shopify Migration
Even with expert help, migrations present challenges that must be strategically addressed:
- Data Structure Differences: Magento and Shopify have different data structures, particularly around product variants (Magento allows 200+ variants, Shopify limits 100 per product). Solution: Specialists employ creative workarounds like using custom options apps or modifying product structures.
- SEO Preservation: Maintaining search rankings is a primary concern. Solution: Implementation of comprehensive 301 redirect strategies and preservation of all metadata.
- Custom Functionality Recreation: Magento stores often include custom-developed features without direct Shopify equivalents. Solution: Experienced developers recreate custom functionalities using Shopify's API and development framework.
- Password Migration: Customer passwords cannot be migrated due to security limitations. Solution: Agencies implement password reset workflows that smoothly guide customers through creating new passwords.
Making the Right Choice for Your Business
Selecting the ideal migration partner depends on several factors specific to your business:
- For Complex B2B Operations: Prioritize agencies like IWD Agency or Ziffity with specific B2B experience.
- For Large Enterprises: Choose partners like Scandiweb or Netalico with proven experience handling complex integrations and enterprise-scale projects.
- For SEO-Sensitive Businesses: Select an agency that highlights their SEO audit and redirect strategy as a core service.
- Always Review Case Studies: Request specific examples of successful migrations for businesses similar to yours, like Netalico's work with Audio Advice.
Conclusion: Positioning Your Business for Future Growth
Migrating from Magento to Shopify Plus represents more than just a platform change—it's an opportunity to reimagine your ecommerce experience and position your business for accelerated growth. The specialized agencies profiled here have repeatedly demonstrated the ability to execute seamless migrations that drive measurable business results.
The proven benefits of successful migration—improved conversion rates, reduced operational overhead, enhanced marketing agility, and revenue growth—make a compelling case for undertaking this strategic initiative. By selecting a partner with the right expertise, methodology, and post-migration support capabilities, you can minimize risk while maximizing the return on your technology investment.
As you consider your migration options, we encourage you to evaluate partners based on their specific experience with businesses like yours, their technical approach to challenging migration aspects, and their ability to serve as long-term strategic partners rather than just implementation vendors.
Ready to explore how migration to Shopify Plus could transform your ecommerce business? The specialists profiled here offer complimentary consultations to discuss your specific needs and develop preliminary migration strategies.
